Banks Ordered to Refund Victims of Phishing Scams Following Landmark Supreme Court Decision

08-05-2025


In a landmark decision, the Spanish Supreme Court has unequivocally placed the responsibility for digital fraud on banks, mandating them to reimburse affected customers immediately unless the bank can prove the customer acted with gross negligence. This ruling, dated April 9, underscores the banks' obligation to enhance their diligence and adopt better practices to detect and prevent fraudulent transactions, leveraging technological advancements to safeguard customers' assets.

The case that led to this pivotal ruling involved a victim of SIM swapping, a sophisticated fraud technique where perpetrators duplicate a victim's SIM card to gain unauthorized access to their digital banking services. The victim lost €83,000 through over fifteen unauthorized transactions conducted overnight. The Supreme Court criticized the bank for failing to detect and halt these transactions, which were markedly out of the ordinary for the customer's typical banking behavior.

The court's decision is rooted in the European Payment Services Directive and Spanish law, which already impose a quasi-objective liability on banks in such scenarios. However, the Supreme Court's ruling now sets a clear legal precedent, emphasizing that banks must employ adequate technological tools to monitor and flag anomalous transactions, such as those occurring at unusual hours or involving unusually large amounts.

This ruling not only reaffirms the banks' duty to protect their customers from digital fraud but also highlights the importance of immediate action by customers to report unauthorized transactions. The Supreme Court's stance is a significant step towards enhancing digital banking security and ensuring that the financial burden of fraud does not unjustly fall on the victims.

Recommended news

Spanish Transport Minister Óscar Puente Celebrates Birth of Third Child at 56

2025-05-15T13:45:08.726Z

Spanish Transport and Sustainable Mobility Minister Óscar Puente has announced the birth of his third child, a son named Óscar Puente III, marking a joyous expansion of his family at the age of 56. The minister shared the news on his social media platform X, accompanied by a tender photograph...

Read more


National Police Detain Parents in Alicante Over Suspected Genital Mutilation of Child

2025-05-15T13:43:11.787Z

In a disturbing case that has come to light in Elche, Alicante, a couple has been arrested by the National Police on suspicion of committing a serious crime against their three-year-old daughter. The parents, a 38-year-old man and a 26-year-old woman, are accused of subjecting their child to...

Read more


Artur Mas Expands Legal Battle to Include Alleged Pegasus Spyware Use During His Tenure

2025-05-15T13:45:53.267Z

Former Catalan President Artur Mas has taken legal action against several high-profile figures from Spain's People's Party (PP), including ex-Interior Minister Jorge Fernández Díaz and former PP Secretary General María Dolores de Cospedal, over allegations of political espionage and the...

Read more


Andalusia Seeks Role in National Blackout Investigation After Government Points to Local Power Failures

2025-05-15T13:46:38.154Z

The regional government of Andalusia has announced its intention to join the national committee of experts investigating the causes of the massive power outage that left all of Spain without electricity and mobile networks on April 28. This move comes after the central government identified...

Read more


Tordesillas and Regional Government Stand Firm on Toro de la Vega Celebration

2025-05-15T13:43:51.189Z

The Ayuntamiento de Tordesillas in Valladolid has announced its intention to exhaust all legal avenues to ensure the celebration of the Toro de la Vega, following a recent court ruling that annulled the 2022 modifications to the event's regulations. The local government, led by Miguel Ángel...

Read more