Spanish Constitutional Court Divided on Waiting for EU Ruling on Amnesty Law

13-05-2025


The Spanish Constitutional Court finds itself at the center of another contentious debate as three of its magistrates, Enrique Arnaldo, César Tolosa, and Concepción Espejel, have requested a halt to the proceedings regarding the amnesty law until the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issues its ruling. This move underscores the ongoing tensions within the court over how to handle the controversial law, which has sparked widespread debate across Spain.

The request by the three magistrates argues that the Constitutional Court should not rule on the Popular Party's appeal against the amnesty law until the CJEU has clarified whether the law conflicts with European Union law. This stance highlights the complexities of navigating between national legal frameworks and EU legal standards, especially in cases with significant political and legal implications.

Meanwhile, the majority of the Constitutional Court's magistrates appear inclined to proceed without waiting for the CJEU's input, signaling a potential rift within the court. This division reflects broader disagreements over the amnesty law's compatibility with both the Spanish Constitution and EU law, as well as the appropriate timing for such a significant legal decision.

The debate over the amnesty law is not just a legal matter but also a deeply political one, with implications for Spain's relationship with the EU and the internal balance of power within the Spanish judiciary. As the Constitutional Court deliberates, the outcome of this dispute will have far-reaching consequences for the rule of law in Spain and its alignment with European legal standards.

Recommended news

Tragedy at Sea: Seven Migrants, Including Children, Die Near Canary Islands

2025-05-29T17:13:10.835Z

In a heartbreaking incident off the coast of El Hierro in the Canary Islands, at least seven migrants, including two five-year-old children and a 16-year-old, lost their lives when their overcrowded boat capsized. The tragedy occurred as the vessel was being towed into the harbor of La...

Read more


Concerns Rise Over Youth Vaping Trends in Catalonia

2025-05-29T17:14:53.869Z

On World Vape Day, British American Tobacco (BAT) emphasized the potential of smokeless nicotine products, such as vapes, heated tobacco, and nicotine pouches, in reducing the harm caused by traditional cigarettes. The company highlighted that these alternatives produce significantly fewer...

Read more


Political Maneuvering in Extremadura: Gallardo Faces Allegations of Legal Fraud

2025-05-26T14:01:54.212Z

Manos Limpias, a Spanish organization known for its legal activism, has filed a complaint against Miguel Ángel Gallardo, a deputy in the Extremadura Assembly, accusing him of procedural fraud and bribery. The complaint alleges that Gallardo, alongside former deputy María Cruz Rodríguez,...

Read more


Puig Sets Sights on 8% Sales Growth by 2025 Amid Market Challenges

2025-05-29T17:14:07.515Z

Puig, the Spanish beauty and fashion conglomerate, has projected a sales growth of 6% to 8% for the year 2025, maintaining its medium-term growth outlook despite a 'certain moderation' in the market, particularly in makeup and skincare. Marc Puig, the company's executive chairman, expressed...

Read more


Man Arrested for Allegedly Shooting Partner Multiple Times in Verín

2025-05-26T14:01:26.386Z

The Civil Guard has detained a man suspected of shooting his partner multiple times in the Ourense municipality of Verín. The incident, which occurred around 2:00 PM this Sunday in the Primero de Maio neighborhood, was reported by neighbors who heard the commotion. The victim, who was...

Read more